Shopify Upselling and Cross-Selling Apps: PageFly Landing Page Builder vs AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does PageFly Landing Page Builder Work?
  3. How Does AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell Work?
  4. How Much Does PageFly Landing Page Builder Cost?
  5. How Much Does AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell Cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: PageFly Landing Page Builder vs. AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


Did you know that increasing customer retention by 5% can boost profits by 25% to 95%? In the context of Shopify stores, upselling and cross-selling are business strategies playing a key role in not just survival but thriving. Upselling and cross-selling apps empower merchants to enhance the shopping experience while maneuvering for evolved revenue. In this sphere, PageFly Landing Page Builder and AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell emerge as two robust tools. These apps integrate seamlessly with multiple platforms and exponentially uplift user experience by providing diversified options that can effectively upscale your business.

How Does PageFly Landing Page Builder Work?

PageFly Landing Page Builder encapsulates an intuitive approach to crafting beautiful web pages that resonate with upselling and cross-selling. It provides a drag-and-drop editor, facilitating merchants and agencies to fashion pages brimming with individuality. Unique functionalities like mobile responsiveness and SEO-friendly page creation open a new realm of possibilities. Whether a business is scaling up or firmly established, PageFly gears them towards a customized, customer-centric outlook. For instance, an emerging startup can leverage the single free page/section to kickstart its online presence, while a large enterprise might tap into the advanced lead-gen library for a more expansive impact. The ease of customization, alignment with any theme, and the boon of responsive design for various screen sizes culminates in a potent blend where PageFly's features exemplify an enhanced process in upselling and cross-selling.

How Does AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell Work?

AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell takes the baton of conversion right after the checkout. Enabling one-click post-purchase offers spurs the average order value, a golden metric for any Shopify store. The app excels with its range of features such as mobile optimization, advanced analytics, and the ability to customize thank you pages. These tools are instrumental, from small businesses looking to nudge their order value slightly, up to high-volume stores demanding rigorous, data-backed upsell strategies. Particularly with Shopify Plus, the checkout page upgrades can be a game-changer. For an emerging small business, the lower-tier plan offering up to 100 orders per month for $7.99 can be cost-effective while testing water in upselling. A larger player, on the other hand, can benefit from the upper tiers that accommodate a greater order influx with enhanced analytics to oversee and refine sales strategies.

How Much Does PageFly Landing Page Builder Cost?

When profitability pivots around increments in customer spend, cost-effective upselling solutions like PageFly gain attention. PageFly’s sole free tier includes full feature access for one page/section, perfectly fitted for startups or businesses with limited needs. There are no hidden charges, affirming the developer's commitment to clear value propositions for enterprises at various levels.

How Much Does AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell Cost?

AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell offers a staggered pricing model that scales with store traffic. Starting at $7.99 for establishments with up to 100 orders, its range extends to $29.99 for businesses with up to 500 orders a month, making its intention clear: grow with your business. There are no additional fees, ensuring transparency for businesses to plan their upselling strategies accordingly.

Cost Analysis: PageFly Landing Page Builder vs. AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell

PageFly excels with its free lifetime access for a single page/section, which is a boon for new entrepreneurs. AfterSell's lowest tier already asks for a commitment, albeit a modest one. For larger stores, AfterSell's structured tiers promise scalability, a feature not as transparent in PageFly's singular pricing model. Each app presents a differing approach to cost, but both hold a considerate stance on providing value.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is PageFly Landing Page Builder Good?

With an impressive 4.9-star rating amassed from 9159 reviews, PageFly's praise likely stems from its user-friendly interface and wide customization options. Its ability to fine-tune every visual aspect to enhance upselling and cross-selling strategies could be a significant contributor to its high rating. As for customer support, although not outlined in the data, one can presume it plays a critical role in PageFly’s success equation, given the industry's emphasis on responsive service.

Is AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell Good?

Matching PageFly, AfterSell boasts a 4.9-star rating, but from 651 reviews. The smaller number suggests a niche but satisfied user base, likely appreciative of its one-click upsell efficiency and analytics. Given the complexity of post-purchase upsell, one can surmise that effective and responsive customer support plays a crucial part in AfterSell's user satisfaction.

User Preference: PageFly Landing Page Builder or AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell?

With a larger user base, PageFly might suggest broader adoption or longevity in the marketplace. However, when it comes to favoring, both apps show equal footing with their ratings. The distinction may lie in their targeted use; PageFly's wide application for landing pages may appeal to users looking for design flexibility, while AfterSell's razor-sharp focus on post-purchase interaction could attract a more conversion-centric audience.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

PageFly Landing Page Builder Integrations:

PageFly's integrations with platforms like Facebook Pixel and Klaviyo are strategic for data-driven marketing and automation. These, among its other integrations, serve to streamline the marketing stack and offer businesses the leverage of interconnected tools.

AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell Integrations:

AfterSell integrates with checkout solutions and review platforms like Loox and Stamped, which not only enrich the post-purchase experience but align with powerful marketing tools to bolster conversion rates. These integrations reveal AfterSell's commitment to a well-rounded upsell strategy.


While PageFly Landing Page Builder champions design personalization and universal compatibility, AfterSell Post Purchase Upsell positions itself as the go-to for immediate conversion optimization post-purchase. User reviews lean towards a highly favorable experience with both apps, indicative of their effectiveness in fulfilling upselling and cross-selling objectives. Strengths & Weaknesses: PageFly stands out in customization flexibility, a strength for merchants who prioritize brand individuality. Conversely, its single pricing model might be a limitation for scaling purposes. AfterSell, meanwhile, boasts a stronghold in increasing order value with a structured pricing approach but may not cater well to those seeking extensive landing page services. Recommendations: For businesses requiring vast customization and design control, PageFly may be the superior choice. In contrast, merchandisers valuing straightforward, targeted upselling immediately after purchase should consider AfterSell. Both tools present substantial utility in upselling and cross-selling, with their choice boiling down to specific business needs and goals.

Still searching for the right fit?

When it comes to maximizing your Shopify store's revenue, selecting the right tools for upselling and cross-selling can make all the difference.

Introducing Frequently Bought Together

Developed by Code Black Belt, this robust app excels in creating product bundles and suggesting personalized recommendations, simulating the successful Amazon strategy right on your Shopify store. Since its launch on March 15, 2017, it has been helping stores like yours leverage the power of AI-driven recommendations to increase the average order value effectively.

Key Features

  • Smart AI Algorithm: Years of refinement have made its recommendations incredibly accurate and tailored to drive up conversion rates.
  • Customizable Bundles: You are in full control to adjust product recommendations and craft impeccable bundles.
  • Flexible Discounts: Apply four different types of discounts to incentivize bundle purchases.
  • Compatible Styling: The app’s widget harmonizes beautifully with your existing theme, also allowing for custom style tweaks.
  • Scalable Performance: Rest assured it can handle any number of products, orders, or traffic with utmost smoothness.

Why We Recommend This App

Frequently Bought Together is your go-to app because it not only understands customer behavior but also adapts to it, giving your customers exactly what they want with just a single click. We're confident in its ability to enhance the shopping experience, hence boosting your sales. It's not just about making a sale; it’s about creating a shopping experience that feels natural and inviting.

Pricing Structure

Starting at $9.99/month after a 30-day free trial, you get access to all the premium features of the app without breaking the bank. Given the wealth of functions and the potential for a significant return on investment, Frequently Bought Together is competitively priced.

Merchant Feedback

With an impressive rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars from 2327 reviews, it’s clear that merchants are benefiting greatly from Frequently Bought Together. They commend its seamless integration, the boost in conversion rates through discounts and bundles, and the exceptional customer service. The tool is not only easy to install and customize but also quick to increase sales and enhance the professional appeal of your online store.

Convert browsers into buyers and elevate the shopping experience on your Shopify store with Frequently Bought Together. It’s time to let the results speak for themselves.

Enhance Your Store Now