Shopify Shipping Labels Apps: AfterShip Returns vs PH Ship, Rate and Track

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does AfterShip Returns Work?
  3. How Does PH Ship, Rate and Track Work?
  4. How Much Does AfterShip Returns Cost?
  5. How much does PH Ship, Rate and Track cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: AfterShip Returns vs. PH Ship, Rate and Track
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


For any e-commerce business, the ability to efficiently manage returns and ship products is not just an operational detail—it's a crucial aspect of customer satisfaction and loyalty. In this competitive landscape, customers expect transparent, quick, and hassle-free shipping and return policies. This is where shipping label apps step in, revolutionizing the post-purchase experience through automation and precision. We'll explore two notable contenders in this field: AfterShip Returns and PH Ship, Rate, and Track. Both have carved out their places within the Shopify ecosystem by offering tools that not just streamline these processes but also augment the customer experience manifold.

How Does AfterShip Returns Work?

AfterShip Returns is an automated solution designed to streamline the returns process for merchants and ease the experience for customers. Its standout features include a customizable returns management portal, automatic label generation, and multilingual return pages, appealing to businesses of all sizes. Smaller ventures can benefit from the free tier to establish a professional returns process, while larger corporations can leverage the full suite of features for a global and scalable returns operation. With AfterShip Returns, businesses can encourage exchanges over returns, directly impacting their bottom line by retaining more revenue. Imagine an international customer receiving updates in their own language—a small feature that can significantly boost customer loyalty and brand image.

How Does PH Ship, Rate and Track Work?

In comparison, PH Ship, Rate and Track focuses on the shipping aspect, integrating seamlessly with FedEx for real-time shipping rates, label printing, and efficient tracking—keeping the store and the customer informed at every step. Its one-tier, straightforward pricing could be particularly attractive for small to medium businesses looking for clarity and simplicity in their shipping processes. With the ability to print various FedEx documents in a click, it exemplifies hassle-free shipping. For webshops with international clientele, the multilingual support circumvents the language barrier, creating an inclusive environment for users across the globe.

How Much Does AfterShip Returns Cost?

Cost efficiency is a driving force for selecting an app, and AfterShip Returns presents several tiers tailored to diverse business needs. The 'Free' tier, at zero cost, brings in basic returns management, perfect for startups testing the waters. Then there's the 'Essentials' plan at $23/month, which introduces automatic labels and basic analytical insights suited for growing businesses. Scaling up, 'Pro' arrives at $59/month with sophisticated rules and multilingual support, while the 'Premium' tier at $239/month caters to enterprises looking for the most extensive options in automating and customizing their return processes. No hidden fees are mentioned, ensuring financial transparency for users.

How much does PH Ship, Rate and Track cost?

PH Ship, Rate and Track offers a unique pricing structure with its 'Unlimited' plan priced at $19/month. This includes real-time rates, label printing, invoicing, and dedicated support. There's a particular simplicity and attractiveness to this single-tier pricing, as it eliminates the decision-making complexity for the user. Considering it integrates powerful FedEx tools, it's a value proposition that's hard to ignore, especially for medium-sized businesses that seek robust shipping options without the layers of complexity.

Cost Analysis: AfterShip Returns vs. PH Ship, Rate and Track

In comparing both, AfterShip Returns provides a tiered pricing model that allows businesses to scale as they grow. In contrast, PH Ship, Rate and Track offers a one-size-fits-all plan that covers most shipping needs. While AfterShip Returns focuses on returns, the pricing of PH Ship, Rate and Track reflects its specialized, yet comprehensive, shipping services.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is AfterShip Returns Good?

With a commendable 4.7-star rating across 2181 reviews, AfterShip Returns exhibits a strong track record. It's plausible that users appreciate its automated features and customizable approach towards handling returns. Good customer support can significantly lift such ratings, and AfterShip Returns likely impresses on that front, given the praise for their automation and regional routing benefits.

Is PH Ship, Rate and Track Good?

Boasting a near-perfect 4.9-star rating from 424 reviews, PH Ship, Rate and Track seems to resonate well with its user base. The simplicity and effectiveness of its shipping management tools are probably central to its high praise. Timely and supportive customer service, especially related to shipping, is paramount and could be a pivotal factor for its exceptional rating.

User Preference: AfterShip Returns or PH Ship, Rate and Track?

Both apps are well-received, though AfterShip Returns has a higher volume of feedback. This can suggest a larger user base or a longer presence in the market. The higher rating for PH Ship, Rate and Track, however, could indicate superior satisfaction with its services among its users.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

AfterShip Returns Integrations:

AfterShip Returns offers seamless integration with key platforms such as Shopify Flow and leading carriers like UPS and FedEx. It's built to simplify, streamline, and enhance the returns process, which can be a godsend for stores with high return volumes.

PH Ship, Rate and Track Integrations:

PH Ship, Rate and Track is tailored for those who extensively use FedEx services, providing direct integration that enhances shipping efficiency. Its single-tier approach is mirroring this simplicity, likely attractive for those who value a no-nonsense shipping process.


AfterShip Returns and PH Ship, Rate and Track each provide strong features in their respective areas, offering tailored solutions for returns and shipping needs. The feedback from thousands of users underlines their effectiveness and impact, with AfterShip Returns leading in scale and PH Ship, Rate and Track in overall satisfaction. Regarding strength and weaknesses, AfterShip Returns is versatile and offers more choice but could be overwhelming for some, while PH Ship, Rate and Track is straightforward but limited to users who only require shipping solutions. Businesses requiring comprehensive return management might find AfterShip Returns to be a better fit, whereas companies seeking a simplified integration for FedEx shipping services might prefer PH Ship, Rate and Track. Both have their merits, and the final decision will rest with individual business needs and preferences.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

Shipping labels are a crucial aspect of any e-commerce business, but they are just one piece of the puzzle when it comes to streamlining your operations. While you've been exploring shipping label solutions, it's worth considering other tools that could enhance your e-commerce store's efficiency. That's where Hulk Form Builder by HulkApps comes into the picture.

Key Features of Hulk Form Builder

Hulk Form Builder is more than just a form creation tool; it's an all-encompassing solution that offers an impressive suite of features to help manage and gather crucial data. With this app, you can:

  • Design both fundamental and sophisticated forms tailored to your store's needs.
  • Implement Google reCaptcha to prevent spam submissions.
  • Customize each element of your form to blend seamlessly with your store's branding.
  • Enable file and image uploads, offering unlimited storage space for your convenience.
  • Configure conditional logic and dynamic field logic for more interactive and user-centric forms.
  • Harness the power of complete mobile responsiveness, ensuring accessibility and performance across all devices.

Why We Recommend Hulk Form Builder

While shipping labels help you get your products to your customers, Hulk Form Builder assists in cultivating valuable interactions. We recommend this app because it:

  • Enhances customer engagement with personalized forms.
  • Streamlines workflows with efficient data collection tools.
  • Integrates effortlessly with established services like Shopify Flow, Klaviyo, Stripe, and more to synchronize your operations.
  • Offers the ability to tailor responses, providing a professional touch to your customer communications.
  • Boasts a user-friendly interface, eliminating the need for coding knowledge to design custom forms.

Pricing Structure

Hulk Form Builder caters to businesses of all sizes with its flexible pricing plans:

  • Basic Plan: Free (Create unlimited forms, export submissions, limitless file uploads, and more)
  • Pro Plan: $9.90/month (Adds UTM tracking, dynamic values, Facebook Pixel integration, etc.)
  • Pro+ Plan: $19.90/month (Integrates with Google Sheets, Slack, Zapier, and increases the upload limit to 100 MB)

Merchant Feedback

With over a thousand reviews and a shining 4.9-star rating, Hulk Form Builder has earned accolades for its intuitive design and multifaceted capabilities. Merchants have applauded its customization options, seamless integrations, and the impeccable support provided by HulkApps.

Feeling Ready to Enhance Your Store's Capabilities?

Transitioning from shipping labels to form-building might seem like a shift, but remember, every component of your e-commerce site adds to a cohesive, user-friendly experience. Hulk Form Builder is a powerful ally in that journey, promising to deliver not just forms but solutions that resonate with both you and your customers.

Embark on the path to amplified customer engagement and operational efficiency today. Try Hulk Form Builder now and witness the transformation in how your store operates, communicates, and thrives. Why wait when excellence is just a click away?