Shopify Popups Apps: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards vs Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Work?
  3. How Does Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup Work?
  4. How Much Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Cost?
  5. How much does Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards vs. Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


Popups have proven to be a powerhouse in the quest for customer engagement and conversion, with some reports indicating an average conversion rate increase of over 3% when they're implemented correctly. In the e-commerce terrain, where every click can lead to a sale, popups serve as both a guide and an incentive for shoppers' journeys. Shopify apps like Smile: Loyalty & Rewards and Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup have emerged as vital tools in this digital landscape. Both apps promise to enrich the customer experience, one by fostering loyalty and the other by leveraging the persuasive power of social proof. They offer seamless integration with Shopify, ensuring merchants can enhance their store functionality without extensive technical know-how. Let's delve into how these apps operate to lift brand engagement and sales.

How Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Work?

Smile: Loyalty & Rewards positions itself as a multifaceted tool for fostering repeat business. It lets merchants set up a points program, referral incentives, and even a VIP system, designed to turn one-time buyers into lifelong customers. The app's ease of setup is commendable, requiring no coding at all, thus becoming an attractive option for businesses of all sizes. The customization features are a boon for brands wishing to maintain a consistent look and feel across all customer touchpoints. It's not just about aesthetics – the actionable nudges and integrations such as Klaviyo and Mailchimp have the potential to significantly amplify engagement rates. The VIP program and point expiry, available in higher-tier plans, allow for meticulous customer segmentation, rewarding the most loyal shoppers and encouraging others to reach similar statuses. Imagine a small business leveraging Smile to introduce a simple points system that cultivates customer loyalty, and then as the brand grows, scaling up to a robust VIP program designed to retain top-tier customers. The tiered structure of the Smile app makes such progressions seamless.

How Does Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup Work?

Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup capitalizes on 'FOMO' – the fear of missing out – by creatively showcasing recent sales and customer activity. This app enables a store to display notifications of others' purchasing behavior, thus incentivizing on-the-fence customers to follow through with their own transactions. Customization takes center stage here as well, allowing businesses to align the popups with their branding, creating a cohesive customer experience. Analytics are a crucial component, providing insights into customer interactions with the popups and thus informing better marketing decisions. For startups dipping their toes into establishing online trust, Proof Bear's basic yet potent sales popups work wonders. For more established stores, customized popups aligned with advanced sales strategies can be a game-changer in conversion optimization.

How Much Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Cost?

Investing in customer loyalty doesn't have to break the bank. Smile offers a free plan with essential features like points and referral programs, effectively catering to new and small businesses keen on building customer relationships. As these businesses grow, they can move to the Starter plan at $49/month, unlocking advanced branding and integrations with key apps. The Growth plan, priced at $199/month, introduces a VIP program and points redemption at checkout for Shopify Plus stores, a boon for medium-sized businesses. At the enterprise level, the Plus plan at $999/month offers premium support and sophisticated reporting tools essential for large-scale operations. Each tier builds upon the former, ensuring businesses only pay for the features they need, with no hidden costs muddying the waters.

How much does Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup cost?

Proof Bear keeps it simple with a straightforward value proposition: it's free. With no tiered pricing or hidden fees, it presents itself as an all-in-one solution for merchants of any size. The value here is undeniable: access to an app that can increase conversions without requiring financial commitment.

Cost Analysis: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards vs. Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup

Comparing the pricing of Smile and Proof Bear paints a vivid picture of divergent business models. Smile's tiered pricing allows businesses to grow their loyalty programs in step with their expansion, potentially delivering more tailored experiences at each stage. Proof Bear's no-cost approach makes it accessible and may deliver immediate uplift in sales for businesses on a tight budget.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Smile: Loyalty & Rewards good?

With an impressive 4.8-star rating from 5653 reviews, Smile stands out as a preferred loyalty app. Merchants often highlight the intuitive interface and impact on customer retention. Rigorous customer support enhances the value proposition, with users frequently praising the guidance provided for loyalty strategies.

Is Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup good?

Proof Bear's 4.9-star rating, derived from 292 reviews, suggests it's a hit with users. Its core strength seems to be its simplicity and immediate impact on sales. Although the number of reviews is smaller compared to Smile's, the near-perfect rating hints at significant user satisfaction.

User Preference: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards or Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup?

The choice between Smile and Proof Bear may stem from distinct business needs rather than a clear favorite. Smile's robust features are ideal for businesses focusing on long-term customer engagement, while Proof Bear's approach fits brands seeking a quick boost in trust and conversions.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Integrations:

Smile boasts integrations with Shopify Flow,, and various email and customer service platforms, ensuring it can slot into a store’s ecosystem with ease. These integrations extend Smile's functionality, helping businesses create a comprehensive experience.

Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup Integrations:

Proof Bear's simplicity extends to its integration approach. While specific integrations were not provided, its ability to work immediately with any app or theme underlines its universal compatibility.


While both Smile: Loyalty & Rewards and Proof Bear ‑ Sales Popup offer unique enhancements to the customer experience, they serve different needs. Smile's multifaceted loyalty programs are perfect for building lasting relationships and brand advocates, whereas Proof Bear's sales popups are instrumental in immediate sales uplifts. From user reviews, it's clear that both apps exceed expectations but in different arenas: Smile with a comprehensive loyalty approach and Proof Bear with its single, focused strategy of social proof. For brands aiming at a loyal customer base with tiered engagement, Smile is the go-to. For those where every sale counts and immediate results are paramount, Proof Bear offers a compelling solution. Both apps have their merits, and the decision lies in aligning with the respective business goals to provide that sought-after popup prowess on Shopify stores.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

If you've been browsing the Shopify app store for an effective solution to enhance your store's engagement through popups, you're likely focused on finding a tool that is both user-friendly and powerful. That's why we'd like to introduce you to Hulk Popups w/ Coupons by

Key Features:

Hulk Popups w/ Coupons is designed to seamlessly integrate into your Shopify store, providing you with a robust set of features to captivate your audience:

  • Email Collection Popups: Grow your mailing list with customizable popups that encourage visitors to subscribe.
  • Discount & Coupon Popups: Boost sales by offering tailored discounts or promotions directly to your site's visitors.
  • Notification Popups: Keep your customers informed about important announcements.
  • 10+ Customizable Templates: Find the perfect look to match your brand from a diverse selection of popup templates.
  • Integration with Klaviyo and Mailchimp: Maximize the effectiveness of your email marketing efforts through seamless integration.
  • Intuitive Setup: Get your popups running in no time with the easy-to-use setup process.

Why We Recommend this App:

As a designer of ecommerce solutions, we understand the importance of a smooth user experience. Hulk Popups w/ Coupons provides a simple yet potent toolset to create the popup engagement you need, without hindering the customer journey on your site. Its 4.8 rating is a testament to its reliability and effectiveness among merchants who have witnessed the benefits first-hand.

Pricing Structure:

Whether you're just starting out or you're looking to optimize an already thriving online store, Hulk Popups w/ Coupons has a plan for you:

  • Free Plan Available: Test the waters with a 7-day free trial and see the impact for yourself.
  • Flexible Premium Plans: Choose from various paid plans as your business needs grow. Please visit our app listing for more details on the pricing options to fit your needs.

Merchant Feedback:

Business owners value transparency and real results. Although we don't have specific merchant feedback to share at this moment, the app's high rating indicates a high level of satisfaction among users who have harnessed its capabilities to drive conversions and engage with their customers.


No two stores are the same, and your popup strategy should reflect the unique appeal of your brand. With Hulk Popups w/ Coupons, you're not just choosing an app; you're paving the way for better customer interactions and sales opportunities.

Ready to uplift your store's engagement with a powerful popup solution? Discover Hulk Popups w/ Coupons today! Let's transform your visitor experience together.