Shopify Popups Apps: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards vs Pixelpop Popups & Banners

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Work?
  3. How Does Pixelpop Popups & Banners Work?
  4. How Much Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Cost?
  5. How much does Pixelpop Popups & Banners cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards vs. Pixelpop Popups & Banners
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


With 500 million daily active users navigating through Shopify stores, popups play a critical role in capturing the fleeting attention of potential customers. Popup apps can enhance the user experience by delivering personalized offers, collecting emails for marketing campaigns, and cultivating customer loyalty. Today, we examine two notable popup apps within the Shopify ecosystem: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards and Pixelpop Popups & Banners. Both platforms provide a rich array of options for engaging shoppers, integrating seamlessly with Shopify, and contributing positively to the customer journey.

How Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Work?

Smile: Loyalty & Rewards transforms one-time buyers into long-term brand advocates through loyalty, referral, and VIP programs. Without the necessity for coding expertise, businesses can rapidly deploy rewards that resonate with their audience. Unique features include default reward emails and analytics overviews for the Free plan, with more sophisticated tools like VIP programs and points redemption at checkout emerging in higher plans. These programs cater to enterprises of varying sizes — from startups to multinational corporations. A business may, for instance, leverage Smile's nudges to re-engage customers who haven't made a purchase in a while, thereby improving customer retention.

How Does Pixelpop Popups & Banners Work?

Pixelpop Popups & Banners capitalizes on targeted engagement, offering seven types of popups, including email signups and coupon codes. With device targeting and customizable images, even a basic user can curate a tailored shopping experience. Its ease of use does not dampen its capabilities which are vast, providing optional controls for more nuanced marketing strategies. Pixelpop might particularly shine for a boutique shop wanting to announce a limited-time offer via sleek, customized popups.

How Much Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Cost?

Cost-effective solutions are paramount for sustaining business growth. presents a tiered pricing model, starting with a robust Free plan. Each successive tier — Starter, Growth, and Plus — introduces progressively advanced features such as advanced branding and API access, meeting the diverse needs and budgets of different businesses. Target audiences range from startups on the Free plan to large enterprises on the Plus plan. There are no hidden fees, making budgeting for customer engagement refreshingly transparent.

How much does Pixelpop Popups & Banners cost?

PixelPop offers four straightforward plans, from the cost-free Basic plan to the Growth plan at $24/month providing up to 50,000 monthly popup views. Each plan promises more views and enhanced features, attracting a variety of users from new entrepreneurs to expanding businesses. With no apparent additional costs, Pixelpop embodies an accessible pricing structure for companies aiming to enhance their immediate customer outreach without a significant investment.

Cost Analysis: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards vs. Pixelpop Popups & Banners

Comparing both apps,’s plans lean towards businesses aspiring for substantial branding and customer loyalty management, whereas Pixelpop's offerings cater to those focusing exclusively on immediate customer engagement through popups. Both provide substantial value at their price points, yet seems a choice for a long-term investment in customer relationships, while Pixelpop excels in on-site customer interactions. Neither app offers explicit promotional discounts, but their entry-level free plans serve as a risk-free introduction to their services.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Smile: Loyalty & Rewards good?

The high average rating of 4.8 stars out of 5653 reviews suggests that users find substantial value in’s functionality. The positive rating could be attributed to the app's user-friendly interface and its effective loyalty programs. Customer support is integral, and's described attentive support team likely contributes to user satisfaction.

Is Pixelpop Popups & Banners good?

Pixelpop holds an impressive 4.7-star rating from 285 reviews. The app's simplicity combined with deep customization features appears to meet, if not exceed, user expectations. Reviews may point towards the balance of simplicity in setup with the depth of features as a significant draw for users.

User Preference: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards or Pixelpop Popups & Banners?

Both apps receive high ratings, suggesting strong user satisfaction; however,'s larger user base might reflect broader utility or stronger customer enticement. The preference could stem from a variety of factors including the scope of engagement – whether the business is seeking immediate conversions or cultivating lasting loyalty.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Integrations:

Smile integrates seamlessly with diverse tools such as Shopify POS or Klaviyo, allowing for an enhanced marketing strategy that leverages existing systems. Users frequently commend the ease of adding Smile to their Shopify store and appreciate the additional functionality obtained through these integrations.

Pixelpop Popups & Banners Integrations:

Pixelpop offers focused integrations with key marketing platforms like MailChimp, simplifying the email marketing process. Users can benefit from combining efficient email marketing with targeted popups, making Pixelpop a potent tool for conversion rates.


Smile: Loyalty & Rewards and Pixelpop Popups & Banners serve distinct but integral roles in popups and customer engagement. prides itself on building and maintaining customer relationships, while Pixelpop specializes in direct, impactful customer engagement tactics. User reviews reflect confidence in both apps' abilities to enhance the ecommerce experience. The integration capabilities of can entwine with broader business processes, whereas Pixelpop offers nimble and striking engagement tools. Strengths & Weaknesses: stands out through its comprehensive loyalty programs and multiple integrations. Areas for improvement could focus on expanding language support and in-plan features. Pixelpop excels with its user-friendly interface and a variety of popup types, potentially enhanced by more robust analytics. Recommendations: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards is well-suited for businesses that value customer retention and brand loyalty, offering a full suite of tools to facilitate these goals. Pixelpop is ideal for those seeking straightforward, yet flexible popup solutions without the need for extensive customizations. Given user feedback and feature sets, businesses must gauge their immediate needs against their long-term strategies when choosing between these robust Shopify popup apps.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

If you've been browsing the Shopify app store for an effective solution to enhance your store's engagement through popups, you're likely focused on finding a tool that is both user-friendly and powerful. That's why we'd like to introduce you to Hulk Popups w/ Coupons by

Key Features:

Hulk Popups w/ Coupons is designed to seamlessly integrate into your Shopify store, providing you with a robust set of features to captivate your audience:

  • Email Collection Popups: Grow your mailing list with customizable popups that encourage visitors to subscribe.
  • Discount & Coupon Popups: Boost sales by offering tailored discounts or promotions directly to your site's visitors.
  • Notification Popups: Keep your customers informed about important announcements.
  • 10+ Customizable Templates: Find the perfect look to match your brand from a diverse selection of popup templates.
  • Integration with Klaviyo and Mailchimp: Maximize the effectiveness of your email marketing efforts through seamless integration.
  • Intuitive Setup: Get your popups running in no time with the easy-to-use setup process.

Why We Recommend this App:

As a designer of ecommerce solutions, we understand the importance of a smooth user experience. Hulk Popups w/ Coupons provides a simple yet potent toolset to create the popup engagement you need, without hindering the customer journey on your site. Its 4.8 rating is a testament to its reliability and effectiveness among merchants who have witnessed the benefits first-hand.

Pricing Structure:

Whether you're just starting out or you're looking to optimize an already thriving online store, Hulk Popups w/ Coupons has a plan for you:

  • Free Plan Available: Test the waters with a 7-day free trial and see the impact for yourself.
  • Flexible Premium Plans: Choose from various paid plans as your business needs grow. Please visit our app listing for more details on the pricing options to fit your needs.

Merchant Feedback:

Business owners value transparency and real results. Although we don't have specific merchant feedback to share at this moment, the app's high rating indicates a high level of satisfaction among users who have harnessed its capabilities to drive conversions and engage with their customers.


No two stores are the same, and your popup strategy should reflect the unique appeal of your brand. With Hulk Popups w/ Coupons, you're not just choosing an app; you're paving the way for better customer interactions and sales opportunities.

Ready to uplift your store's engagement with a powerful popup solution? Discover Hulk Popups w/ Coupons today! Let's transform your visitor experience together.