Shopify Popup Apps: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards vs Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Work?
  3. How Does Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell Work?
  4. How Much Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Cost?
  5. How much does Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards vs. Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


Did you know email pop-ups can increase subscription rates by over 1,375%? It's little wonder why pop-up apps play a pivotal role in enhancing online shopping experiences and boosting conversion rates. On Shopify's app store, countless plugins promise to transform customer engagement. Two notable contenders in this arena are Smile: Loyalty & Rewards and Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell. Both offer a suite of functionalities designed to level up the user experience. They stand out not only for their range of options but also for their seamless integration with existing platforms and the significant impact they have on customer loyalty and sales.

How Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Work?

Smile: Loyalty & Rewards is a tool designed to craft loyalty and rewards programs, propelling first-time customers into long-term brand advocates. It delivers a points program, referral system, and VIP tiers that can be set up within minutes. Features like customizable emails, on-site nudges, and an analytics dashboard make it an asset to any business size seeking to nourish their customer relationships. Small businesses may appreciate the basic yet comprehensive free plan, while larger enterprises could leverage the full suite of features, including advanced segmentation and priority support in the higher-tier plans. All businesses can benefit from the app's integrations, like Klaviyo and Mailchimp, fostering a cohesive marketing strategy that nurtures customer engagement and incentivizes repeat purchases.

How Does Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell Work?

On the other side, Personizely is a dynamic widget that merges popups with upsell functionalities, helping stores escalate their conversion rates. With Personizely, you can design popups that capture emails, offer exit-intent deals to reduce cart abandonment, and nudge customers towards higher-value items. The app is intuitive, catering to businesses of all sizes looking to implement personalized upsell and cross-sell strategies effectively. Its A/B testing capability is a boon, allowing businesses to refine offers for optimal AOV (Average Order Value) growth. Integrations with platforms like ActiveCampaign and Mailchimp infuse marketing efforts with actionable customer insights, bolstering both the user experience and the bottom line.

How Much Does Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Cost?

Smart financial planning is crucial in ecommerce, and Smile understands this. Its free plan is a solid start, offering the essentials. As businesses grow, investing $49/month unlocks advanced branding and integrations, while the $199/month Growth plan introduces a VIP program and more sophisticated reward options, targeting more established businesses. For the power users, the Plus plan at $999/month includes unparalleled support and data segmentation. No hidden fees mean businesses can predict their costs and measure ROI transparently.

How much does Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell cost?

Intersecting value with affordability, Personizely's offerings start with a free Development plan, scaling up to the Essential Plus plan at $99/month, which is ideal for stores requiring extensive customization options without the added weight of branding from the app itself. Premium support across all paid plans underlines the app's commitment to user experience—essential for stores where every interaction counts.

Cost Analysis: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards vs. Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell

When weighing Smile against Personizely, both present diverse pricing strategies. Smile's higher-tier options suggest it's catered towards larger stores, anchoring in strategic loyalty plans. Personizely, with its modular pricing, seems more flexible, especially appealing to those focused on conversion optimization and sales motivation. While promotional offerings are nuanced, delineating a clear winner in cost-efficiency is a matter of pinpointing specific business needs in the pop-ups and loyalty landscape.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Smile: Loyalty & Rewards good?

With a starry 4.8 rating pooled from 5653 reviews, Smile: Loyalty & Rewards comes across as a beloved option. It's likely that users find its ease of use, comprehensive features, and exceptional loyalty-building capacity the crowning features. Support is hinted to be a high point in the app's journey, aligning customer service quality with the overall user satisfaction.

Is Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell good?

Personizely's perfect 5-star rating, albeit from a smaller pool of 223 reviews, suggests a robust approval among its users. The app's streamlined user interface and the effectiveness of its pop-ups and upsell capabilities might explain its pristine rating. Premium support, consistent across plans, likely further cements user trust and satisfaction.

User Preference: Smile: Loyalty & Rewards or Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell?

Smile's larger number of reviews indicate a wider user base and possibly a longer presence in the market, which translates to tested reliability. However, Personizely's perfect score could imply a higher per-user satisfaction, potentially owing to its focused conversion-boosting toolkit. The decision between the two may revolve around whether a business prioritizes comprehensive loyalty features or is more conversion-centered.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

Smile: Loyalty & Rewards Integrations:

Smile integrates with an impressive lineup including Shopify POS and Shopify Flow, creating a seamless omnichannel experience. Pairing Smile's loyalty system with the like of marketing apps such as Klaviyo allows for automated, targeted outreach that can significantly lift customer retention and advocacy.

Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell Integrations:

Personizely casts a wide net, connecting to top-tier email marketing tools such as Omnisend and ActiveCampaign. These integrations translate to informed upselling and cross-selling strategies that sync well with existing campaigns, giving users a holistic toolkit to scale up their revenue.


Both Smile: Loyalty & Rewards and Personizely ‑ Popups & Upsell deliver compelling features, with Smile shining in creating deep-rooted customer loyalty and Personizely excelling in conversion rate optimization. User reviews applaud Smile for its robustness and Personizely for its precision. Strengths & Weaknesses: Smile’s strengths lie in loyalty and long-term customer value maximization, whereas Personizely offers distinct advantages in instant engagement and sales uplift. Areas of improvement for both apps are bound, with Smile potentially escalating its user interface and Personizely broadening its loyalty features. Recommendations: Consider Smile if your business strategy prioritizes customer retention and brand loyalty. Turn to Personizely when immediate sales increase and a deeper understanding of customer behavior are your primary goals. Ultimately, the right choice will echo your business's ethos and strategic market positioning within the wealth of options pop-ups offer.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

If you've been browsing the Shopify app store for an effective solution to enhance your store's engagement through popups, you're likely focused on finding a tool that is both user-friendly and powerful. That's why we'd like to introduce you to Hulk Popups w/ Coupons by

Key Features:

Hulk Popups w/ Coupons is designed to seamlessly integrate into your Shopify store, providing you with a robust set of features to captivate your audience:

  • Email Collection Popups: Grow your mailing list with customizable popups that encourage visitors to subscribe.
  • Discount & Coupon Popups: Boost sales by offering tailored discounts or promotions directly to your site's visitors.
  • Notification Popups: Keep your customers informed about important announcements.
  • 10+ Customizable Templates: Find the perfect look to match your brand from a diverse selection of popup templates.
  • Integration with Klaviyo and Mailchimp: Maximize the effectiveness of your email marketing efforts through seamless integration.
  • Intuitive Setup: Get your popups running in no time with the easy-to-use setup process.

Why We Recommend this App:

As a designer of ecommerce solutions, we understand the importance of a smooth user experience. Hulk Popups w/ Coupons provides a simple yet potent toolset to create the popup engagement you need, without hindering the customer journey on your site. Its 4.8 rating is a testament to its reliability and effectiveness among merchants who have witnessed the benefits first-hand.

Pricing Structure:

Whether you're just starting out or you're looking to optimize an already thriving online store, Hulk Popups w/ Coupons has a plan for you:

  • Free Plan Available: Test the waters with a 7-day free trial and see the impact for yourself.
  • Flexible Premium Plans: Choose from various paid plans as your business needs grow. Please visit our app listing for more details on the pricing options to fit your needs.

Merchant Feedback:

Business owners value transparency and real results. Although we don't have specific merchant feedback to share at this moment, the app's high rating indicates a high level of satisfaction among users who have harnessed its capabilities to drive conversions and engage with their customers.


No two stores are the same, and your popup strategy should reflect the unique appeal of your brand. With Hulk Popups w/ Coupons, you're not just choosing an app; you're paving the way for better customer interactions and sales opportunities.

Ready to uplift your store's engagement with a powerful popup solution? Discover Hulk Popups w/ Coupons today! Let's transform your visitor experience together.