Shopify Loyalty & Rewards: Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program VS Seal Subscriptions App

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program Work?
  3. How Does Seal Subscriptions App Work?
  4. How Much Does Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program Cost?
  5. How Much Does Seal Subscriptions App Cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program vs. Seal Subscriptions App
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Conclusion


Did you know that, according to a report by Forbes, it is approximately five times more expensive to acquire a new customer than it is to retain an existing one? The value of loyal customers cannot be overemphasized, especially in a heavily competitive marketplace. One of the best ways to retain customers is through loyalty and rewards programs. These programs not only incentivize repeat business but also improve customer engagement and satisfaction. Today, we're covering two heavyweights in the Shopify app market that help businesses do just that: Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program and Seal Subscriptions App.

How Does Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program Work?

Developed by Joy Loyalty, the Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program aims to enrich customer experience and foster consumer loyalty. It offers an easy-to-use solution that doesn't impede your shop's loading speed. Its key feature includes a comprehensive points reward and redeem system which encourages customers to keep coming back. Whether you're a startup figuring out your customer retention strategy, a medium-sized business looking to incentivize purchases or a large enterprise aiming to create a VIP experience, Joy can make it happen. Imagine this: A customer visits your online store, makes a purchase, and earns points. They see the amount of points they have accrued and are incentivized to make another purchase to reach the reward threshold. It's a win-win scenario: the customer feels valued and rewarded, and in turn, your customer retention rates soar.

How Does Seal Subscriptions App Work?

Seal Subscriptions App is a similar player in the Shopify app market, but its focus is slightly different and oriented towards managing recurring revenue through subscriptions. Developed by Seal Subscriptions, it's designed to be user friendly, offering merchants an effortless way to set up their first subscription rule and start generating recurring revenue. The core features include adjustable delivery profiles, product swap options, and tiered discounts for different subscriber levels. Whether you are a beginner dipping your toes in selling subscription boxes or a titan of the subscription economy, Seal Subscriptions App has something for you.

How Much Does Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program Cost?

Investing in a loyalty and rewards program can boost your customer retention rates substantially. However, the costs need to align with the value the app will bring to your business. The Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program offers two pricing tiers. The Free plan offers a limit of 250 orders/month, and enables businesses to set up an earn points program. It also allows integrations and customization of email content. It is suited for small businesses looking to leap into the rewarding world of loyalty programs. The Pro plan comes in at $29/month and includes features such as customizable emails, full POS integration, unlimited points rewards, and redeem programs. This plan is ideal for businesses that have a high volume of orders and require a robust loyalty program.

How Much Does Seal Subscriptions App Cost?

Like Joy, Seal Subscriptions App also offers a tiered pricing system. The Free for life! plan allows up to 150 subscriptions and offers features such as multi-language support, auto-charge & recurring invoices, product swap, auto update delivery costs, and tiered discounts. Ideal for small businesses or startups looking to delve into the subscription model. The SUPERSALE plan costs $4.95/month and caters to businesses with more advanced needs such as global statistics insight, API & webhooks, and provision for up to 750 subscriptions. The RISING STAR plan ($7.95/month) and LEGEND plan ($20/month) ramp up accordingly with more features included for businesses with a growing number of subscriptions.

Cost Analysis: Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program vs. Seal Subscriptions App

It's evident that both apps offer different value propositions for different business needs. While Joy is more focused on a free-to-pro solution that allows for easy implementation of a loyalty plan, Seal Subscriptions App offers more granular control with four different pricing options catering to an array of business sizes and complexities.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program Good?

According to the data from Shopify, the app has an impressive average rating of 4.9 stars, as voted by 1260 users. Given the focus on retention and loyalty these high ratings may stem from the effectiveness of the loyalty program system they offer, as well as the customer service they provide.

Is Seal Subscriptions App Good?

Seal Subscriptions App also has a stellar average rating of 4.9 stars, based on 934 reviews. The variety of subscription management features they offer, paired with an exceptional level of user satisfaction, could be contributing factors to the app's high praise.

Which App is Better according to users?

Both apps excel in user satisfaction, based on the high ratings and the number of users that have reviewed the apps. From the data available, users seem to find both apps beneficial, making selection more of a choice based on business need rather than overall user sentiment.

Integrations and Compatibility

Joy: Loyalty & Rewards Program Integrations:

The Joy app integrates seamlessly with apps like Shopify POS, Checkout, Shopify Flow, POS, PageFly, Transcy,, Klaviyo, Loox, offering an elevated user experience and making the usage smoother and more efficient.

Seal Subscriptions App Integrations:

Seal Subscriptions App, on the other hand, integrates with different software and tools such as Klaviyo, Google Analytics, Bundler, Pagefly, Gempages, PayPal Subscription, which can aid businesses in tracking, managing, and executing their subscription model effectively.

Our Top Recommendations For Your Store

While loyalty and rewards programs are key to retaining customers, other tools can also play a significant role in enhancing customer engagement and trust. Here are three apps that can help you build a stronger connection with your customers:

SC Conjured Referrals

Encourage your customers to become brand advocates with SC Conjured Referrals. This app helps you create a referral program that rewards your customers for sharing your products. It’s user-friendly and integrates directly with your Shopify admin, offering a free plan with more robust options starting at $19/month. Merchants appreciate its straightforward setup and the positive impact on sales.
Want to harness the power of word-of-mouth? Try out SC Conjured Referrals today.

Hulk Mobile App Builder

Beyond loyalty programs, providing a seamless mobile shopping experience can significantly increase customer retention. The Hulk Mobile App Builder allows you to create a native mobile app for your Shopify store without any coding. With features like real-time push notifications and a comprehensive dashboard, starting at $79/month, it's a valuable asset for any merchant looking to boost mobile engagement.
Ready to go mobile? Build your app with Hulk Mobile App Builder.

Opinew Product Reviews App UGC

Trust is essential in ecommerce, and displaying authentic customer reviews can help establish that trust. Opinew Product Reviews App UGC enables you to collect and showcase customer reviews, including photo and video reviews. This app offers a free plan and advanced features from $19/month, making it a favorite for its user-friendly interface and excellent customer support.
Looking to build trust with reviews? Start with Opinew today.

Each of these apps offers unique features that can help you improve customer engagement and trust, which are crucial for building loyalty. Which one will you integrate into your Shopify store first?