Shopify Product Review Apps: Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+ vs Editorify ‑ Product Reviews

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+ Work?
  3. How Does Editorify ‑ Product Reviews Work?
  4. How Much Does Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+ Cost
  5. How much does Editorify ‑ Product Reviews cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+ vs. Editorify ‑ Product Reviews
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion

Introduction

In an age where e-commerce drives the economy and customer loyalty means everything, the voice of the customer has never been more significant. In fact, did you know that 97% of online customers deem customer reviews as crucial while making purchasing decisions? The customer's virtual word-of-mouth, product reviews, play a critical role in building credibility, enhancing product visibility, improving service quality, and most importantly - increasing conversions and sales. Thus, to optimize the collection and presentation of reviews, we turn our attention to “Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+” and “Editorify - Product Reviews”, which offer innovative solutions for Shopify stores.

How Does Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+ Work?

Vitals, developed by a namesake team, is more than a simple product review manager—it's a comprehensive tool chest filled with over 40 smart features for upselling, cross-selling, requests for reviews, and more. What’s more, it can be integrated seamlessly with your Shopify store without any slowdowns. The features include Wishlist, urgency notifications, email & push marketing, Instagram feed, currency converter, size chart, back in stock, and much more. Each feature is designed to help startups grow, assist a Small to Medium Business (SMB) to scale, and enable a large enterprise to maintain its growth trajectory by boosting conversion rates and aiding in customer retention.

How Does Editorify ‑ Product Reviews Work?

Editorify, on the other hand, targets Shopify merchants who want to leverage the power of social proof through genuine customer reviews. With the ability to import reviews from multiple wholesalers like AliExpress, Alibaba, Etsy, and more, Editorify allows merchants to build and showcase real and authentic product reviews. This highly responsive software makes it feasible to display the reviews on various screen sizes while matching the aesthetics of your store template. A unique feature includes the Profanity Filter, allowing automatic removal of reviews containing improper language, thereby promoting positive customer engagement.

How Much Does Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+ Cost

For a tool packed with over 40 features, Vitals only comes with four pricing tiers. Starting from as low as $29.99/month (Hobby plan for startups with limited needs) to an enterprise-level plan for $299.99/month (Plus, with no limit on features). Each plan begins with a 7-day trial which can be extended to 30 days with no extra fee—a powerful incentive for trying out the app risk-free.

How much does Editorify ‑ Product Reviews cost?

Editorify offers a cost-efficient and accessible solution with its four-tier pricing methodology. For a newbie Shopify merchant just getting their store off the ground, the Free plan offers a limit of 50 product reviews. As you scale your business, choose between the Premium and Gold plans at $9.95/month and $14.95/month, respectively. Larger businesses with diversified product offerings can opt for the Diamond Plan at $24.95/month, which provides unlimited reviews, amongst other features.

Cost Analysis: Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+ vs. Editorify ‑ Product Reviews

When comparing the cost of both apps, one might say Vitals offers a more comprehensive package of features suitable for a merchants with greater demands. Conversely, Editorify might seem a more favorable option for those looking for a cost-effective review-focused app. However, do remember, both apps offer trial periods allowing you to assess their capabilities before committing to a plan.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+ good?

Scanning the user feedback for Vitals, an average rating of 5 stars from 6066 reviews is quite indicative of its popularity among Shopify merchants. Going by such glowing reviews, users might be appreciating the app’s multitude of features, user-friendliness, and its impact on conversions.

Is Editorify ‑ Product Reviews good?

Editorify is not far behind, garnering an average rating of 4.8 stars, courtesy of 446 reviews. Users seem to enjoy the simplicity, functionality, and the ability of the app to foster genuine customer engagement through authentic reviews.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

Vitals: Reviews, Upsells & 40+ Integrations:

Vitals excels highly in this area with smooth integrations with numerous platforms like Facebook Messenger, Klaviyo, Facebook Pixel, Instagram, and a host of others, which augment the functionality of your Shopify store.

Editorify ‑ Product Reviews Integrations:

Contrarily, the data provided does not indicate any specific integration capabilities from Editorify. Regardless, it doesn't take away its effectiveness as a stellar product review prompter and manager.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

If you haven't settled on a review app after our comparison, you might want to explore the Shopify Product Reviews & Ratings App by HulkApps. With a 4.7-star rating from over 300 users, this app is more than just a tool—it's a solution. Here's a snapshot of its standout features:

Smart AI Approval:

This tool auto-publishes positive reviews. It means your store always shows the best feedback, helping build trust with shoppers.

Social Sharing:

Share customer reviews easily on social media platforms. It's a great way to let more people know about the good things customers are saying.

Photo Reviews:

Customers can add photos to their reviews. It gives others a real look at what they can expect.

Custom Fields:

Add up to 5 extra fields in your review form. It helps you get more specific feedback about things like product size, color, or delivery.

Structured Data:

Improve your store's online visibility. Show customer review counts in search results, making your products stand out more.

HulkApps offers different plans to fit your needs, including a free option. Check out the HulkApps Product Reviews for a full review solution.