Shopify Gift with Purchase Apps: Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts vs Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts Work?
  3. How Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Work?
  4. How Much Does Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts Cost?
  5. How Much Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts vs. Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


Purchasing patterns are evolving—more than ever, customers are drawn to the allure of added value. Findings reveal that 57% of shoppers express that a gift with purchase significantly sways their decision-making process. Within this burgeoning niche, technologies like gift with purchase apps have emerged as vital tools for online retailers. Fostering customer loyalty and incentivizing higher spending, these tools are revolutionizing the e-commerce landscape. In this light, two notable apps, Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts and Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator, stand out for their robust capabilities. These apps seamlessly integrate with Shopify to empower store owners with innovative strategies to enhance customer experience and augment sales. Let's delve into their features and assess their impact on e-commerce ventures.

How Does Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts Work?

Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts, by Monster Apps, serves as a sophisticated vehicle for elevating average order value. The app is tailor-made to enrich shopping carts with a suite of upselling options—such as progress bars, free gifts, and discounts—that amplify the checkout experience without the disruptive influence of popups. For different business scales, it carves out avenues to boost revenue: startups can test the waters with evergreen offers, SMBs can harness the power of event-driven campaigns, and large enterprises can capitalize on rich, layered promotion strategies. Its unique functionality, such as the 'One Tick Upsell Offers', targets the nuanced needs of dynamic sales strategies, making it a game-changer in the art of unobtrusive upselling.

How Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Work?

Conversely, Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator, developed by Digismoothie, plays the role of an invisible sales booster through psychological nudges. This app permits the configuration of gift rules that entice shoppers to surpass spending thresholds. For businesses of all sizes, gift personalization based on customer behavior is an asset: it affords burgeoning stores the capacity to charm new customers, while larger establishments can bolster their efforts in customer loyalty programmes. Gift Box's magnetic appeal lies in its simplicity—the straightforward setup eschews the need for technical prowess, making it an attractive choice for those seeking frictionless marketing refinements.

How Much Does Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts Cost?

Resource allocation is pivotal, and Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts presents variously tiered pricing plans. The 'Partners Stores' plan is a cost-free entree, ideal for development stores diving into a trial phase. As businesses grow, the 'Up To 50 Orders' plan, at $12.99/month, inaugurates a comprehensive suite of features for burgeoning ventures seeking to cement their market foothold—minus any operational constraints or hidden costs.

How Much Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Cost?

Similarly, the Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator app beckons with scalable investment. Starting at a discounted rate of $19.99/month for Shopify Basic stores, the utility scales up to $199.99/month for Shopify Plus businesses, signaling its adaptability across diverse operational sizes. No concealed fees ensure an honest and transparent relationship—integral for brands prioritizing straightforwardness in their tools.

Cost Analysis: Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts vs. Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator

When juxtaposed, both apps offer promotional undertakings—50% off initial months with Gift Box, and an entirely free plan option with Monster Cart. Deciphering which app provides superior economic leverage pivots on individual business objectives, audience, and desired functionalities.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts Good?

With a stellar 4.8-star reputation from 521 reviews, Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts earns laudation likely rooted in its diverse, customer-centric capabilities. Moreover, an undercurrent of satisfaction might prevail courtesy of its unintrusive approach to sales enhancement—a trait potentially reflected in its auspicious ratings.

Is Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Good?

Gift Box stands slightly ahead with a 4.9-star rating from 157 reviews. Its charm, presumably, lies in the deftness of its user experience and the tangible impact of its free gifts scheme on shopper behaviour. The fewer number of reviews, however, might imply that while quality is pronounced, its market penetration might not yet rival that of its comparative.

User Preference: Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts or Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator?

The higher review count for Monster Cart may suggest broader acceptance or longer market presence. In contrast, Gift Box's slightly superior rating intimates a potentially deeper user satisfaction—though it caters to a smaller user base. Preferences could oscillate based on whether one prioritizes breadth of adoption or peak user experience.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts Integrations:

Integration is a cakewalk with Monster Cart, offering seamless compatibility with Pagefly and a clutch of checkout and localization apps. These alliances ensure a versatile performance, reinforcing its standing as a holistic, powerful enhancement to the Shopify experience.

Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Integrations:

Gift Box deftly integrates with apps like Currency Converter, Cand Rack, suggesting a focused approach that tackles profiled conversion and upselling challenges. Its integration processes are nimble, facilitating an intuitive merger with existing Shopify functionalities.


Deciphering the most suitable app entails a nuanced analysis—weighing Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts' extensive feature set and mass appeal against Gift Box's pristine user satisfaction and conversion-oriented functionality. Strengths & Weaknesses: Monster Cart sparkles with its exhaustive feature breadth and customer-centricity, whilst Gift Box scores on simplicity and niche effectiveness. Potential growth areas are evident in both, with Monster Cart dialing up its compatibility and Gift Box expanding its user base. Recommendations: For multifaceted customization needs and broad usage, Monster Cart Upsell+Free Gifts edges forward, while Gift Box is the quintessence of user-experience finesse and targeted incentives. Both apps embody the phenomenon of customer delight, yet the scale of operation and desired simplicity versus versatility will direct the final choice.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

If you've been on the hunt for the perfect app to enhance your Shopify store's allure through gifts and rewards, you may not have considered the power of volume discounts to drive customer loyalty and increase sales. While you weigh your options in the 'Gift with Purchase' category, let’s introduce you to an adept alternative that could revolutionize the way you do business.

Introducing VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts by HulkApps

At HulkApps, we've developed a robust solution to incentivize bulk purchases, drive larger order values, and reward your loyal customers. VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts is a comprehensive app that caters to merchants looking for an automated tiered pricing system that works seamlessly on Shopify stores.

Key Features of VolumeBoost

  • Tiered Discounts Made Simple: Create a range of discount levels to encourage higher purchase volumes and boost your average order value.
  • Dynamic Cart Messages: Keep your customers informed with customizable messages about how much more they need to spend to reach the next discount level.
  • Customer Tagging: Implement targeted discounts by creating and storing multiple customer tags for personalized offers.
  • Bulk Discount Limits: Maintain full control over your promotion strategies by managing the quantity available for your bulk discount offers.
  • Global Reach: Activate bulk discounts for selected countries, expanding your sales strategy on a global scale.
  • Effortless Navigation: A user-friendly interface that enables you to set up complex offers with ease.

Why We Recommend VolumeBoost

The VolumeBoost app is not just about slashing prices; it's about strategically growing your business. It's designed to attract new customers, retain existing ones, and cleverly enhance the overall value of each purchase—all which align seamlessly with loyalty-building efforts often seen in 'Gift with Purchase' promotions.

Additionally, with a 4.6 rating and 1165 reviews since its launch on February 27, 2018, the app's reputation speaks for itself. It works in synergy with popular tools like Google Analytics, Facebook Pixel, and our very own HulkApps Mobile App Builder.

Transparent Pricing Structure

VolumeBoost offers a transparent pricing model, starting from an affordable $10/month, including a 7-day free trial option. This tiers based on the scale and needs of your business, making it an ideal investment for any stage of your growth.

Merchant Feedback

Shop owners have consistently lauded VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts for its effectiveness at offering unique, quantity-based discounts not readily available on Shopify. Its seamless integration and customizable design have been game-changers for businesses looking to ramp up their sales and enhance customer satisfaction.

Are You Ready to Elevate Your Sales Game?

You've witnessed the power and flexibility of VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts, and how its key features can align with your goals of nurturing customer loyalty and increasing sales. Why not take your promotions strategy to the next level?

Ready to revolutionize your discount strategy? Dive into the world of VolumeBoost now.

Join the myriad of success stories and let VolumeBoost help you craft a pricing strategy that turns occasional shoppers into lifelong customers.