Shopify Gift with Purchase Apps: Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift vs Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Work?
  3. How Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Work?
  4. How Much Does Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Cost?
  5. How much does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift vs. Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


Gift with purchase is an age-old marketing strategy that has stood the test of time, proving to be as effective in today's digital marketplace as it was in traditional retail. These helpful apps themselves can increase average order value and customer loyalty—benefits any business would welcome. Let's take a close look at Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift and Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator, two prime Shopify apps that let merchants weave the art of gifting into their online stores with ease and effectiveness.

How Does Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Work?

Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift is designed to elevate the average order value (AOV) through a series of strategic upselling and cross-selling prompts, accompanied by free gifts and more. It gives merchants the power to create tailored experiences and offers at various stages of the customer's journey. The app excels in offering a tiered progress bar and allowing the upgrading of one-time purchases to subscriptions directly in the cart, features that greatly benefit small to medium businesses eager to increase their AOV and customer retention rates. Moreover, large enterprises can leverage highly targeted campaigns with Monk's sophisticated eligibility system. A hypothetical scenario where a merchant uses the upsell feature could lead to customers adding related items to their initial purchase, thus increasing both AOV and customer satisfaction due to the seamless experience.

How Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Work?

Emphasizing customer spending incentives, Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator facilitates the offering of free products based on customized purchasing rules defined by the merchants. Whether it's a startup offering a complimentary item on a customer's first purchase to create a memorable unboxing experience, or a large enterprise diversifying its array of gifts to cater to a broad audience, the app's interface is straightforward and requires no coding expertise. A standout feature is the app's ability to let customers choose their own gifts, thereby enhancing the personalization of the shopping experience and potentially boosting customer retention.

How Much Does Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Cost?

When it comes to pricing, Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift offers a fully free plan for development and partner stores, which is a boon for startups. Their GROWTH I plan at $30/month includes a no commission on sales clause, which is especially useful for small to medium businesses seeing a steady rise in transactions. The $80 GROWTH II plan is targeted at stores processing over a thousand orders a month, indicating suitability for larger scale operations. There are no hidden fees, and its tiered features echo a commitment to providing businesses of varying sizes exactly what they need without overcharging.

How much does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator cost?

Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator also caters to a range of business sizes with its structured pricing plans. The introductory half-price discount period for Shopify Basic and Standard stores eases new users into the app. The top-tier offering for Shopify Plus stores at $199.99/month includes unlimited free gifts and the option to pause the subscription, ideal for high-volume businesses looking for extensive support and flexibility.

Cost Analysis: Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift vs. Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator

A cost-benefit assessment suggests that Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift offers a sweet deal for startups with its fully free plan, while Gift Box has an attractive 50% discount for new basic users. Both apps provide concrete value at different scales; however, Monk's higher-tier offering appears to give more for less when you factor in the additional upselling and subscription upgrade features.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift good?

The stellar 4.9-star rating across 380 reviews suggests high user satisfaction with Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift. It's reasonable to infer that businesses appreciate the app's comprehensive features and customizability, potentially contributing to such positive feedback. The app also advertises support for Shopify Markets and multiple currencies, which could be highly valued by international stores—a fact that likely enhances customer support impressions.

Is Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator good?

Similarly, the 4.9-star rating—though from 157 reviews—indicates that Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator stands its ground in terms of user approval. This app works well for businesses focusing on fortifying their marketing with free gifts and tends to attract positive reactions due to its compatibility with discount codes and gift choices boosted by its customer support.

User Preference: Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift or Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator?

Comparing user reception, both apps share high praise; however, Monk's larger volume of reviews may suggest a broader user base or longer-established trust. It's likely due to Monk's varied features that cater to different stages of the buying journey, while Gift Box focuses specifically on the motivator of free gifts.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Integrations:

Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift boasts seamless integration with Shopify Checkout, enabling smooth transaction enhancements. Users can anticipate an integration that does not disrupt the existing checkout process, thus preserving the customer experience while leveraging the additional monetization opportunities.

Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Integrations:

Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator integrates effortlessly with Currency Converter and Candy Rack apps. This easy integration empowers merchants with flexibility in currency conversion and additional upselling opportunities, respectively, enriching the overall usability and functionality of the app.


Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift and Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator each provide distinctive approaches to offering gift with purchase experiences. Both apps are well-received by users and offer remarkable features, advanced customizability, and solid integration capabilities. Strengths & Weaknesses: Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift shines with its diversified upselling features and advanced customization, while its complexity may pose a slight learning curve for new users. Gift Box flaunts its user-friendly interface and the freedom it offers customers in gift selection, though it may lack some of the more advanced sales-driving features of its counterpart. Recommendations: For a business seeking an extensive suite of sales-enhancement tools combined with gift options, Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift could be the ideal choice. On the flip side, if simplicity, straightforward gifting rules, and cost-effective solutions are the priority, Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator would be a smart pick. Both apps exhibit excellence in their domain, making the choice largely dependent on the specific business needs and operational scale.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

If you've been on the hunt for the perfect app to enhance your Shopify store's allure through gifts and rewards, you may not have considered the power of volume discounts to drive customer loyalty and increase sales. While you weigh your options in the 'Gift with Purchase' category, let’s introduce you to an adept alternative that could revolutionize the way you do business.

Introducing VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts by HulkApps

At HulkApps, we've developed a robust solution to incentivize bulk purchases, drive larger order values, and reward your loyal customers. VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts is a comprehensive app that caters to merchants looking for an automated tiered pricing system that works seamlessly on Shopify stores.

Key Features of VolumeBoost

  • Tiered Discounts Made Simple: Create a range of discount levels to encourage higher purchase volumes and boost your average order value.
  • Dynamic Cart Messages: Keep your customers informed with customizable messages about how much more they need to spend to reach the next discount level.
  • Customer Tagging: Implement targeted discounts by creating and storing multiple customer tags for personalized offers.
  • Bulk Discount Limits: Maintain full control over your promotion strategies by managing the quantity available for your bulk discount offers.
  • Global Reach: Activate bulk discounts for selected countries, expanding your sales strategy on a global scale.
  • Effortless Navigation: A user-friendly interface that enables you to set up complex offers with ease.

Why We Recommend VolumeBoost

The VolumeBoost app is not just about slashing prices; it's about strategically growing your business. It's designed to attract new customers, retain existing ones, and cleverly enhance the overall value of each purchase—all which align seamlessly with loyalty-building efforts often seen in 'Gift with Purchase' promotions.

Additionally, with a 4.6 rating and 1165 reviews since its launch on February 27, 2018, the app's reputation speaks for itself. It works in synergy with popular tools like Google Analytics, Facebook Pixel, and our very own HulkApps Mobile App Builder.

Transparent Pricing Structure

VolumeBoost offers a transparent pricing model, starting from an affordable $10/month, including a 7-day free trial option. This tiers based on the scale and needs of your business, making it an ideal investment for any stage of your growth.

Merchant Feedback

Shop owners have consistently lauded VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts for its effectiveness at offering unique, quantity-based discounts not readily available on Shopify. Its seamless integration and customizable design have been game-changers for businesses looking to ramp up their sales and enhance customer satisfaction.

Are You Ready to Elevate Your Sales Game?

You've witnessed the power and flexibility of VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts, and how its key features can align with your goals of nurturing customer loyalty and increasing sales. Why not take your promotions strategy to the next level?

Ready to revolutionize your discount strategy? Dive into the world of VolumeBoost now.

Join the myriad of success stories and let VolumeBoost help you craft a pricing strategy that turns occasional shoppers into lifelong customers.