Shopify Gift with Purchase Apps: Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator vs GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Work?
  3. How Does GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO Work?
  4. How Much Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Cost?
  5. How much does GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator vs. GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


Gifts with purchase are proven to enhance customer satisfaction and incentivize further spending. In the realm of online retail, these promotional strategies can significantly bolster conversion rates and average order values. The Shopify ecosystem is enriched with apps designed to seamlessly integrate such strategies into e-commerce stores. Two noteworthy options in this space are "Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator" and "GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO." Both excel in offering flexible and diverse gift with purchase options, yet they differ in their approach, features, and cost.

How Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Work?

Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator by Digismoothie allows Shopify store owners to offer customized gifts to their customers based on specific spending thresholds or item selections. Key features include a variety of gift rules, an auto-add to cart functionality, compatibility with existing discount codes, and the option for customers to choose their gift. This app suits businesses of all sizes, from startups to large enterprises, due to its scalability and the power to tailor free gifts to various market segments. For example, a high-traffic enterprise store may use the app to automatically add a free branded merchandise item to orders over $200, thereby enhancing brand loyalty and customer retention.

How Does GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO Work?

GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO by GoodApps, is user-friendly and allows for the creation of custom free gift offers. Its features enable retailers to increase average order value (AOV) by setting conditions for free gifts, such as "Buy X, Get Y" or "BOGO" (Buy One Get One free) deals. It's particularly helpful for small and medium businesses looking to entice customers with straightforward gift offers without disrupting the shopping experience. For instance, a mid-sized clothing store may run a promotion for a free scarf with every two sweaters purchased, promoting additional sales and clearing inventory efficiently.

How Much Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Cost?

The pricing model of Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator consists of several tiers, addressing various business sizes and needs. The "SHOPIFY BASIC -50%" plan is $19.99/month for the first three months, then $39.99 thereafter; it targets newly established Shopify Basic stores. The "STANDARD SHOPIFY" plan at $24.99/month, doubling after the first three months, is crafted for Standard Shopify stores looking to upscale gift offerings. For top-tier merchants, the "SHOPIFY PLUS" plan at $199.99/month includes the option to pause subscriptions, catering to their complex needs. Additionally, a free "TRIAL & DEV" plan offers all features to trial and development stores.

How much does GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO cost?

Unfortunately, the pricing information for GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO is not available. This could imply that GoodApps opts for a different approach to pricing, which may include custom solutions based on individual retailer requirements or possibly a one-size-fits-all plan that remains undisclosed.

Cost Analysis: Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator vs. GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO

While Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator offers transparent, tiered pricing suitable for stores at different stages of growth, GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO has not provided specific cost information. It's essential for potential users to inquire directly with GoodApps for accurate figures. However, the lack of disclosed pricing may hinder immediate cost comparisons.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator good?

With a high rating of 4.9 stars from 157 reviews, Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator appears to resonate positively among its users. The app's ease of use, diverse features, and robust support options suggest that customers are satisfied with the value provided. While specific customer support insights aren't provided, the emphasis on chat and email support in the app’s description aligns with the overall positive user sentiment.

Is GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO good?

GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO holds a strong rating of 4.8 stars from 126 reviews, signaling that it’s well-received by its customer base. This app seems to meet the needs of Shopify merchants looking for a user-friendly solution to gift with purchase promotions. Given the absence of detailed support information, retailers may consider the average rating as an indicator of general app reliability and user satisfaction.

User Preference: Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator or GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO?

Based on ratings and reviews, both apps enjoy a favorable reception. Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator garners slightly higher ratings but without a substantial difference in the number of reviews. Users might lean toward the app offering features more aligned with their business goals or those looking for specific integration capabilities.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Integrations:

Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator integrates with Currency Converter and Candy Rack, providing additional functionality for global currency handling and upselling. Its compatibility with commonly used tools ensures a frictionless implementation.

GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO Integrations:

The information regarding GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO's integrations is not available, posing potential limitations or uncertainties regarding its compatibility with various e-commerce tools and platforms.


"Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator" and "GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO" both offer formidable solutions for Shopify retailers looking to incentivize their customers through gifts with purchase. User reviews suggest confidence in both apps' ability to enhance e-commerce experiences. The primary integrations of Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator suggest a slight edge in flexibility. Strengths & Weaknesses: Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator boasts extensive features, customizable options, and clear pricing, though it may be cost-prohibitive for smaller operations. GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO's strengths lie in simplicity and ease of campaign creation, but it's hampered by the lack of transparency in pricing and integrations. Recommendations: Retailers seeking a comprehensive suite of customizable gift options might prefer Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator. Those prioritizing ease of use and possibly cost efficiency (pending pricing details) may lean towards GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO. Ultimately, the choice will hinge on a store's specific needs within the gift with purchase framework, and an exploration of both apps' offerings is highly recommended.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

If you've been on the hunt for the perfect app to enhance your Shopify store's allure through gifts and rewards, you may not have considered the power of volume discounts to drive customer loyalty and increase sales. While you weigh your options in the 'Gift with Purchase' category, let’s introduce you to an adept alternative that could revolutionize the way you do business.

Introducing VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts by HulkApps

At HulkApps, we've developed a robust solution to incentivize bulk purchases, drive larger order values, and reward your loyal customers. VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts is a comprehensive app that caters to merchants looking for an automated tiered pricing system that works seamlessly on Shopify stores.

Key Features of VolumeBoost

  • Tiered Discounts Made Simple: Create a range of discount levels to encourage higher purchase volumes and boost your average order value.
  • Dynamic Cart Messages: Keep your customers informed with customizable messages about how much more they need to spend to reach the next discount level.
  • Customer Tagging: Implement targeted discounts by creating and storing multiple customer tags for personalized offers.
  • Bulk Discount Limits: Maintain full control over your promotion strategies by managing the quantity available for your bulk discount offers.
  • Global Reach: Activate bulk discounts for selected countries, expanding your sales strategy on a global scale.
  • Effortless Navigation: A user-friendly interface that enables you to set up complex offers with ease.

Why We Recommend VolumeBoost

The VolumeBoost app is not just about slashing prices; it's about strategically growing your business. It's designed to attract new customers, retain existing ones, and cleverly enhance the overall value of each purchase—all which align seamlessly with loyalty-building efforts often seen in 'Gift with Purchase' promotions.

Additionally, with a 4.6 rating and 1165 reviews since its launch on February 27, 2018, the app's reputation speaks for itself. It works in synergy with popular tools like Google Analytics, Facebook Pixel, and our very own HulkApps Mobile App Builder.

Transparent Pricing Structure

VolumeBoost offers a transparent pricing model, starting from an affordable $10/month, including a 7-day free trial option. This tiers based on the scale and needs of your business, making it an ideal investment for any stage of your growth.

Merchant Feedback

Shop owners have consistently lauded VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts for its effectiveness at offering unique, quantity-based discounts not readily available on Shopify. Its seamless integration and customizable design have been game-changers for businesses looking to ramp up their sales and enhance customer satisfaction.

Are You Ready to Elevate Your Sales Game?

You've witnessed the power and flexibility of VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts, and how its key features can align with your goals of nurturing customer loyalty and increasing sales. Why not take your promotions strategy to the next level?

Ready to revolutionize your discount strategy? Dive into the world of VolumeBoost now.

Join the myriad of success stories and let VolumeBoost help you craft a pricing strategy that turns occasional shoppers into lifelong customers.