Shopify Gift with Purchase Apps: BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y vs Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y Work?
  3. How Does Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Work?
  4. How Much Does BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y Cost?
  5. How Much Does Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: BOGOS: Free Gift & Buy X Get Y vs. Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


Gifts with purchases are proven conversion boosters, tipping the scales for customers hesitating at the checkout. A compelling gift can transform a one-time buyer into a loyal patron, increasing the average order value and substantially aiding customer retention. Shopify store owners are not new to this concept and often leverage Gift with Purchase apps to automate and scale these strategies. Two such apps, "BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y" by Secomapp and "Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift" by Monk Commerce, excel not only in diversifying the opportunities for merchants to incentivize purchases but also in integrating smoothly with various platforms, inevitably enhancing the overall shopping experience.

How Does BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y Work?

At its core, "BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y" focuses on a spectrum of custom gifting options. From 'buy one, get one' to 'free gifts with purchase', the app is designed to nudge visitors towards conversion. Specifically, it allows store owners to offer gifts based on cart value, or when specific items are purchased. For a business, be it a burgeoning enterprise or an established player, this opens a lane to create tailored campaigns that resonate with their unique customer base. Picture a scenario where a start-up uses this tool to offer a signature accessory as a complimentary item on a first-time purchase. Not only does this sweeten the deal, but it also embeds a positive brand image in the consumer's mind.

How Does Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Work?

Conversely, "Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift" positions itself as an Average Order Value (AOV) enhancer. The application shines with its sophisticated eligibility engine, which ensures that the right customers see the most compelling offers across their shopping journey. The fully customizable designs and multi-currency compatibility make it a staple for stores of all sizes—especially those that operate globally. Imagine using this tool to showcase a suite of products that complement the customer's current picks or rewarding high-value carts with exclusive items. The app's nuanced upsell strategies can be a goldmine for conversion optimization.

How Much Does BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y Cost?

Investing in a cost-effective solution that offers tangible returns is crucial for businesses. "BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y" comes with four pricing tiers. The Basic plan at $29.99/month serves smaller shops looking to engage and convert their first-time visitors. The Professional plan at $49.99/month is apt for growing stores, while the Unlimited plan at $69.99/month is tailored for larger operations needing extensive reach. Finally, the Plus plan at $99.99/month caters to high-volume stores, such as those on Shopify Plus, seeking holistic campaign management without constraints.

How Much Does Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Cost?

"Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift" also offers tailored plans. Uniquely, it includes a FULLY FREE plan for development stores, a boon for those in the testing or launch phase. Its GROWTH I plan, at a competitive $30/month, includes comprehensive upsell features and is intended for growing stores looking to maximize their cart value. For larger stores processing over a thousand orders a month, the GROWTH II plan, at $80/month, offers an expansive suite of sales-boosting tools.

Cost Analysis: BOGOS: Free Gift & Buy X Get Y vs. Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift

Considering the pricing models of both apps, "BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y" delivers a stepped approach catering to varying degrees of Shopify store advancements. On the other hand, "Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift" flexes a value-loaded proposition, especially with its free offering for development stores. Discounts, trial periods, and flexible pricing help establish the cost efficiency of both, but preferences might sway depending on specific needs, such as the desire for comprehensive integrations or specialized sales strategies.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y Good?

With a stellar 4.8-star rating across 1507 reviews, "BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y" is evidently held in high regard. This acclaim likely stems from its customizable offerings and ease of use. Moreover, praised customer support indicates a company attuned to its clientele, emphasizing the solution’s reliability.

Is Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Good?

"Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift" garners near-perfect praise with a 4.9-star rating from 380 reviews. Its users often highlight the detailed customization and targeted upsell capabilities as key benefits. The app’s robust performance and customer-centric functionalities contribute significantly to its favourable reception.

User Preference: BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y or Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift?

While both apps boast high ratings, the larger volume of reviews for "BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y" suggests a broader user base and adoption. This could be due to its longer presence in the market. Nonetheless, the slightly higher rating for "Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift" intimates strong user satisfaction, possibly due to its nuanced sales strategies and design flexibility.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y Integrations:

"BOGOS: Free Gift & Buy X Get Y" stands out with a suite of integrations, including Checkout, Facebook Pixels, and gift card functionalities. These integrations suggest a well-rounded approach to streamlined shopping experiences and marketing efforts.

Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift Integrations:

While "Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift" lists Checkout as its main integration, its compelling design customization and multi-currency compatibility are points of focus. This indicates a deliberate concentration on versatility and global applicability.


Parsing through both "BOGOS: Free gift & Buy X Get Y" and "Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift" reveals apps rich in features and steeped in user satisfaction. Each offers a unique angle on gift with purchase strategies: the former excels in customizable offerings and seamless integration, while the latter is noted for its sophisticated targeting and design agility. Considering user reviews and integration capabilities, the choice between the two may hinge on specific business needs—whether that's a preference for an all-encompassing approach offered by "BOGOS" or the detailed customization and AOV focus of "Monk Cross Sell & Free Gift." In the realm of tailored promotions and maximized value, both apps hold their own, empowering Shopify merchants to refine the art of the upsell and convert customers with compelling incentives.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

If you've been on the hunt for the perfect app to enhance your Shopify store's allure through gifts and rewards, you may not have considered the power of volume discounts to drive customer loyalty and increase sales. While you weigh your options in the 'Gift with Purchase' category, let’s introduce you to an adept alternative that could revolutionize the way you do business.

Introducing VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts by HulkApps

At HulkApps, we've developed a robust solution to incentivize bulk purchases, drive larger order values, and reward your loyal customers. VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts is a comprehensive app that caters to merchants looking for an automated tiered pricing system that works seamlessly on Shopify stores.

Key Features of VolumeBoost

  • Tiered Discounts Made Simple: Create a range of discount levels to encourage higher purchase volumes and boost your average order value.
  • Dynamic Cart Messages: Keep your customers informed with customizable messages about how much more they need to spend to reach the next discount level.
  • Customer Tagging: Implement targeted discounts by creating and storing multiple customer tags for personalized offers.
  • Bulk Discount Limits: Maintain full control over your promotion strategies by managing the quantity available for your bulk discount offers.
  • Global Reach: Activate bulk discounts for selected countries, expanding your sales strategy on a global scale.
  • Effortless Navigation: A user-friendly interface that enables you to set up complex offers with ease.

Why We Recommend VolumeBoost

The VolumeBoost app is not just about slashing prices; it's about strategically growing your business. It's designed to attract new customers, retain existing ones, and cleverly enhance the overall value of each purchase—all which align seamlessly with loyalty-building efforts often seen in 'Gift with Purchase' promotions.

Additionally, with a 4.6 rating and 1165 reviews since its launch on February 27, 2018, the app's reputation speaks for itself. It works in synergy with popular tools like Google Analytics, Facebook Pixel, and our very own HulkApps Mobile App Builder.

Transparent Pricing Structure

VolumeBoost offers a transparent pricing model, starting from an affordable $10/month, including a 7-day free trial option. This tiers based on the scale and needs of your business, making it an ideal investment for any stage of your growth.

Merchant Feedback

Shop owners have consistently lauded VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts for its effectiveness at offering unique, quantity-based discounts not readily available on Shopify. Its seamless integration and customizable design have been game-changers for businesses looking to ramp up their sales and enhance customer satisfaction.

Are You Ready to Elevate Your Sales Game?

You've witnessed the power and flexibility of VolumeBoost - Volume Discounts, and how its key features can align with your goals of nurturing customer loyalty and increasing sales. Why not take your promotions strategy to the next level?

Ready to revolutionize your discount strategy? Dive into the world of VolumeBoost now.

Join the myriad of success stories and let VolumeBoost help you craft a pricing strategy that turns occasional shoppers into lifelong customers.