Shopify Buy One, Get One (BOGO) Apps: Engines ‑ Discount Box vs Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Engines ‑ Discount Box Work?
  3. How Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Work?
  4. How Much Does Engines ‑ Discount Box Cost?
  5. How Much Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Engines ‑ Discount Box vs. Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


In the world of e-commerce, enticing buyers to add just one more item to their purchase can make a significant impact on a store's bottom line. One strategy that has proven effective time and again is the Buy One, Get One (BOGO) deal—a powerful tool to drive sales, clear inventory, and reward loyal customers. With the right BOGO app, merchants can easily set up appealing offers to enhance the shopping experience and boost their average order value.

In this blog, we explore two such Shopify apps designed to help retailers deploy these deals with ease: Engines ‑ Discount Box and Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator. Both applications enable a wide array of BOGO options and other promotions, integrate seamlessly with Shopify, and have the potential to positively affect a store’s overall experience.

How Does Engines ‑ Discount Box Work?

Engines ‑ Discount Box by WebContrive is a comprehensive BOGO and discount app for Shopify merchants. It facilitates a variety of promotions, including volume breaks, tier discounts, and wholesale offers, all of which can be applied to specific products, collections, or sitewide.

For businesses of all sizes, whether they are startups, SMEs, or larger enterprises, the app allows the creation and display of customized discounts strategically designed to drive increased sales volume. Succinctly, Engines ‑ Discount Box can empower a small boutique to roll out specialized, time-limited offers, or help large wholesalers with complex discount structures to easily manage bulk orders.

Moreover, the unique feature set includes the ability for merchants to offer deals such as 'Buy X Get Y,' or to present free gifts as part of a promotion, thereby maximizing the appeal to shoppers. Imagine a scenario where customers looking to buy gifts during the holiday season are tempted to buy more due to enticing BOGO offers that appear right in their cart—this is where Engines ‑ Discount Box shines.

How Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Work?

Digismoothie's Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator also leverages the power of promotional gifts to increase sales and customer loyalty. It provides tools for merchants to offer free items based on well-defined rules, with gifts automatically added to the customer’s cart to incentivize spending.

For the diversity of the business world, from startup agility to the complexity of an established operation, Gift Box allows seamless customization of gift offers without technical overhead. An apparel store might, for instance, utilize this app to incentivize higher spends by offering a free accessory when a certain purchase threshold is crossed, aligning with the consumer's aspirational needs.

Furthermore, compatibility with discounts gives the battle-front retailers the flexibility of crafting irresistible offers. Customers can enjoy a discount code alongside their free gift, perfect for creating a robust promotional campaign that feels personalized.

How Much Does Engines ‑ Discount Box Cost?

Value in offerings extends beyond features to cost. Engines ‑ Discount Box delivers various pricing tiers designed to match the needs and capacities of different business models. Starting from the BASIC PLAN at $19/month to the SHOPIFY PLUS plan at $99/month, each tier scales up with the scope of services, tailored not only to provide BOGO options but also the likes of wholesale discounts.

Though devoid of additional fees, it's worth noting that as business needs evolve, so might the necessity to graduate to a higher plan to maintain optimization of offerings within this app.

How Much Does Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Cost?

Similarly, Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator offers a range from the half-priced SHOPIFY BASIC option for new stores to the tailored SHOPIFY PLUS tier for $199.99/month for high-volume businesses. The introductory discounts serve as an incubator for nascent enterprises before normalizing to standard rates. Also notable is the TRIAL & DEV tier, permitting new and development stores to exploit all features gratis—an opportunity for entrepreneurs to test the waters.

Cost Analysis: Engines ‑ Discount Box vs. Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator

When comparing the cost structures of Engines ‑ Discount Box and Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator, it's clear that the initial investment in either can be similar. However, the lifetime value, additional features, and scaling possibilities diverge. Gift Box's higher-end plans point to a focus on serving high-traffic stores, while Engines manages a more consistent scale-up suitable for steadily growing enterprises.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Engines ‑ Discount Box Good?

A 4.6-star rating from 240 users indicates a positive reception towards Engines ‑ Discount Box. Customers likely appreciate its vast array of discount options and the app's ability to cater to myriad sale scenarios. Support for Shopify POS further sweetens the deal for retailers looking for a unified discount system.

Is Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Good?

The Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator, with its 4.9-star rating from 157 reviewers, is evidently meeting customer expectations. Its uncomplicated setup and free gift rules resonate well with those aiming to implement hassle-free promotions. The high rating suggests exemplary ease of use and effectiveness.

User Preference: Engines ‑ Discount Box or Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator?

The higher rating but fewer reviews for Gift Box imply a particularly satisfied but potentially smaller user base, whereas Engines ‑ Discount Box, with more reviews but a slightly lower rating, reflects a broader acceptance. The varied features suggest that user preference may hinge on specific business needs and how well each app meets them.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

Engines ‑ Discount Box Integrations:

Engines ‑ Discount Box’s key integration is with Shopify POS, which is indicative of its approach to offer a seamless omnichannel experience. The ease with which it integrates into existing operations presents a straightforward pathway to enhancing sales through discounts and BOGO deals.

Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator Integrations:

Gift Box, with its integrations inclusive of popular tools like Currency Converter and Candy Rack, offers a broader compatibility spectrum. This expands the horizons for businesses exploring international markets or looking to provide an upscaled shopping cart experience.


Both Engines ‑ Discount Box and Gift Box | Free Gift Motivator showcase their unique advantages in offering BOGO and other promotional deals. Engines stands out for shops requiring advanced discounting structures, while Gift Box scoops favor for its ease of use and free gift-oriented approach.

Review insights suggest customer satisfaction runs high for both, albeit with a slight preference for the simplicity of Gift Box. Integration capabilities favor Gift Box in terms of variety, but Engines ‑ Discount Box shows strength in delivering a comprehensive solution within the Shopify ecosystem, particularly for those also using Shopify POS.

Moving forward, merchants must weigh their need for advanced discount structures against the desire for ease and range of gift promotions. The choice between the two apps will be guided by individual business needs, customer engagement strategies, and intended promotional outcomes within the bustling realm of e-commerce sales.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

When it comes to enhancing your Shopify store's offering with Buy One, Get One (BOGO) deals, it's vital to have the tools that allow for seamless product customization and options. While BOGO apps focus on promotions, the SC Product Options app by Shop Circle goes a step further, providing in-depth product customization that can be an excellent complement to any promotion you run.

Key Features

SC Product Options (formerly known as Bold) offers an arsenal of tools to enrich your product pages:

  • Limitless customization: Introduce infinite variants and options.
  • Advanced conditional logic: Exhibit smart and related product choices.
  • Color swatches and variant images: Make it visually appealing and user-friendly.
  • Text boxes and file uploads: Cater to personalized customer requests.
  • Reduce returns: Offer exact customization to minimize unnecessary returns.

Why We Recommend SC Product Options

Selecting the right app to complement your BOGO deals and overall business strategy is crucial. Here’s why we stand behind SC Product Options:

  1. Enhance Product Value: By offering tailored options, you add intrinsic value to your products, which can work hand-in-hand with BOGO deals to provide customers more reasons to purchase.
  2. Upsell Opportunity: This tool can be the engine behind increased Average Order Values (AOV) by promoting complementary customized products alongside BOGO offers.
  3. High Compatibility: The app's compatibility with other Shopify services ensures a smooth operational flow within your store.
  4. Customer Satisfaction: Customization can lead to higher satisfaction as customers receive products tailored to their specific needs.

Pricing Structure

Whatever your store's size, there's a plan that fits:

  • Basic: For $14.99/month, unlock unlimited options and round-the-clock support.
  • Premium: At $39.99/month, you get everything from Basic plus upsell features and more advanced customization capabilities.
  • Developer: Experiment with the app for free on your dev store, and only start paying once you go live.

Merchant Feedback

A strong average rating of 4.7 stars garners trust, and feedback from merchants highlights the value SC Product Options adds — both to the store management process and the bottom line.


A BOGO deal attracts, but the ability to thoroughly personalize a product is what endears customers to your brand. Hence, integrating SC Product Options into your Shopify store could be the differentiator you need.

Ready to elevate your customers' shopping experience? Explore SC Product Options today and see how a simple integration can lead to meaningful outcomes for your store.