Shopify Buy One, Get One (BOGO) Apps: Engines ‑ Discount Box vs. GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. How Does Engines ‑ Discount Box Work?
  3. How Does GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO Work?
  4. How Much Does Engines ‑ Discount Box Cost?
  5. How Much Does GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO Cost?
  6. Cost Analysis: Engines ‑ Discount Box vs. GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO
  7. User Reviews & Customer Support Insights
  8. Integration and Compatibility Comparison
  9. Conclusion


In the realm of e-commerce promotions, the BOGO deal stands as one of the most effective strategies to entice customers and increase sales. By offering an additional product free of charge with a purchase, merchants can clear inventory quickly while giving customers a feeling of obtaining more value for their money. Within this promotional landscape, BOGO apps like Engines ‑ Discount Box and GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO have carved out a niche in the Shopify ecosystem, empowering merchants with a suite of dynamic options to captivate and retain customers.

How Does Engines ‑ Discount Box Work?

Engines ‑ Discount Box is a multifaceted app that allows sellers to tailor discounts to their customer's shopping habits. It’s a powerful tool that encompasses volume and quantity breaks along with wholesale offers. Its capabilities extend to scheduled offers and manual orders, making it friendly for both B2B and B2C environments. Unique features such as the upsell BOGO and General, Cart, Gift discounts position it as a versatile contender, suitable for engaging customers across various segments.

How Does GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO Work?

GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO simplifies the art of gifting in e-commerce. By automating the process of adding a free product to a cart, it optimizes the customer journey, enhancing the overall shopping experience. Its approach promotes increasing the average order value (AOV) — a boon for any business looking to extract more value from existing traffic. The focus of GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO is to incentivize larger purchases through gifts, a tactic that's both simple and effective.

How Much Does Engines ‑ Discount Box Cost?

The Engines ‑ Discount Box offers a tiered pricing structure that caters to businesses of all sizes. Starting at $19/month for the Basic Plan, going up to $99/month for the Shopify Plus, each tier builds upon the last, offering additional functionality suitable for growing businesses. The inclusion of wholesale discounts as a feature across all plans demonstrates a strategic approach to attracting both individual customers and larger buyers.

How Much Does GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO Cost?

While specific pricing details for GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO were not provided, the emphasis on creating customizable offers hints at a flexible and potentially cost-effective solution. Merchants interested in this app may find themselves attracted to its streamlined customer journey enhancement capabilities.

Cost Analysis: Engines ‑ Discount Box vs. GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO

Without complete pricing information for GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO, a direct comparison is challenging. However, Engines ‑ Discount Box offers a clear, structured approach to pricing that scales with a business's needs, which can be advantageous for detailed budget planning.

User Reviews & Customer Support Insights

Is Engines ‑ Discount Box good?

With an impressive 4.6-star rating from 240 reviews, Engines ‑ Discount Box seems to enjoy a favorable reputation. Its broad range of features and commitment to versatility likely contribute to its high rating. Customer support plays a vital role, and although specific mentions of it are not provided, it's implied within the positive feedback loop observed through its ratings.

Is GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO good?

Boasting a 4.8-star rating from 126 reviews, GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO appears to be well-received, despite its shorter time on the market. Its focused offer creation tools are straightforward, suggesting ease of use may be a key factor in its higher rating.

User Preference: Engines ‑ Discount Box or GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO?

When comparing the two apps, GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO has an edge in ratings, though Engines ‑ Discount Box has a larger user base. The preference could be influenced by the specific needs of merchants, with GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO potentially appealing more to those seeking a specialized solution, whereas Engines ‑ Discount Box attracts a wider audience seeking diverse features.

Integration and Compatibility Comparison

Engines ‑ Discount Box Integrations:

Engines ‑ Discount Box integrates with Shopify POS, suggesting it is well-equipped to handle both online and physical retail needs. This integration indicates a smooth omnichannel sales process for merchants.

GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO Integrations:

Despite the lack of detailed integration information for GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO, its targeted approach to gifting implies that it's potentially less dependent on complex integrations, focusing on the core offering of enhancing customer purchases through free products.


Both Engines ‑ Discount Box and GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO offer robust options for the BOGO strategy but cater to subtly different merchant needs. Engines ‑ Discount Box's breadth of features and tiered pricing support a wide range of business sizes, while GA: Free Gift, Buy X Get Y+BOGO's simplicity and high user satisfaction highlight its strength in focused gift offering strategies. Depending on the size, needs, and growth phase of a business, each app serves a unique value proposition that can be leveraged to enhance sales and enrich the customer shopping experience.

Still Searching for the Right Fit?

When it comes to enhancing your Shopify store's offering with Buy One, Get One (BOGO) deals, it's vital to have the tools that allow for seamless product customization and options. While BOGO apps focus on promotions, the SC Product Options app by Shop Circle goes a step further, providing in-depth product customization that can be an excellent complement to any promotion you run.

Key Features

SC Product Options (formerly known as Bold) offers an arsenal of tools to enrich your product pages:

  • Limitless customization: Introduce infinite variants and options.
  • Advanced conditional logic: Exhibit smart and related product choices.
  • Color swatches and variant images: Make it visually appealing and user-friendly.
  • Text boxes and file uploads: Cater to personalized customer requests.
  • Reduce returns: Offer exact customization to minimize unnecessary returns.

Why We Recommend SC Product Options

Selecting the right app to complement your BOGO deals and overall business strategy is crucial. Here’s why we stand behind SC Product Options:

  1. Enhance Product Value: By offering tailored options, you add intrinsic value to your products, which can work hand-in-hand with BOGO deals to provide customers more reasons to purchase.
  2. Upsell Opportunity: This tool can be the engine behind increased Average Order Values (AOV) by promoting complementary customized products alongside BOGO offers.
  3. High Compatibility: The app's compatibility with other Shopify services ensures a smooth operational flow within your store.
  4. Customer Satisfaction: Customization can lead to higher satisfaction as customers receive products tailored to their specific needs.

Pricing Structure

Whatever your store's size, there's a plan that fits:

  • Basic: For $14.99/month, unlock unlimited options and round-the-clock support.
  • Premium: At $39.99/month, you get everything from Basic plus upsell features and more advanced customization capabilities.
  • Developer: Experiment with the app for free on your dev store, and only start paying once you go live.

Merchant Feedback

A strong average rating of 4.7 stars garners trust, and feedback from merchants highlights the value SC Product Options adds — both to the store management process and the bottom line.


A BOGO deal attracts, but the ability to thoroughly personalize a product is what endears customers to your brand. Hence, integrating SC Product Options into your Shopify store could be the differentiator you need.

Ready to elevate your customers' shopping experience? Explore SC Product Options today and see how a simple integration can lead to meaningful outcomes for your store.